MODERATOR: Welcome to another episode of Clash of
Worldviews. Tonight we’re fortunate to have with us in the studio Fred Gulpa,
self-described alt right transhumanist; Rich Goldfarb, a fiery young Jewish
conservative debater; Adam Garnett, noted liberal secular humanist; and Heather
Fogarty, hypermodern skeptic and gadfly. Welcome to all of you and to our
viewers joining us from around the world. Tonight the topic is postmodern
conservatism. What does it mean to be a conservative in the twenty-first
century, under advanced technoscientific, postindustrial conditions? Who would
like to start us off?
RICH: That’s a preposterous question and you’re an imbecile
for asking it. Your hair is all messed up and I’m appalled by your cheap
aftershave, which I’m aghast to say I can smell all the way from over here. So
you must be a closet liberal, which is unfortunate because all liberals are
evil.
MODERATOR: Uh, oh…kay? That wasn’t quite the response I was
looking for. I understood that you’re a professional debater, Rich. Have you
learned about ad hominem attacks?—not
to mention red herrings, since I’m just the moderator here.
![]() |
| Ben Shapiro, inspiration for Rich Goldfarb |
RICH: You see that’s just like a liberal. Run from your liberalism
all you like, but it’s a disgrace.
You want to know what conservatism means today. I’ll tell
you: it means standing up for divine or natural rights against tyrannies like
the liberal state that holds a gun to your head to push corrupt liberal values
down your throat and to collect ill-gotten taxes to grow its Mafioso hold over
the population. The liberal government is an incompetent bureaucracy that can’t
do anything right except shake down its citizens, disrupt the free flow of
market competition, and expand the cushy public sector for the pack of liberal
cronies. Conservatism means respecting the traditions that connect us with
what’s right in the world so that we can oppose what’s evil. And liberalism is
evil. Liberalism boils down to kleptocratic communism: the liberal state wants
to redistribute money that was earned in market transactions, which means the
government steals from the rich to give to the poor—like Robin Hood, except
that instead of a hero, the government is evil. Stealing is wrong. And like
cancer, the liberal state needs runaway growth in its tyrannical powers to
protect unnatural liberal morality, including silly rights for women’s equality
with men, for the killing of babies, for politically-correct recognition of
absurdities such as the wholesomeness of homosexuality, and for government
boondoggles like its nonsolutions to the overhyped problem of global warming.
ADAM: I mean: wow. Just, wow. It’s safe to say there must
have been a hundred strawmen in that screed.
RICH: Everything I just said is obviously correct. You’re an
execrable monster and a charlatan and a demonic insect for suggesting
otherwise.
HEATHER: Uh, Rich, I think someone neglected to inform you
that Clash of Worldviews isn’t like the infotainment newshour shows or campus
debates you’re used to having, in which the goal is to pwn your opponent with
vile hate speech and cheap zingers. We’ll actually expect some arguments here
and won’t be impressed by schoolyard tactics.
RICH: Thanks for the tip. But everything I said is still
obviously correct. There is no counterargument for liberals, since all liberals
ever do is call conservatives bad names. Liberals are the ones with no
arguments, and that’s because liberals are—
ADAM: —evil. That’s what you were going to say, right? Yeah,
that shtick’s going to get old real fast. You’re starting to sound like Ben
Shapiro.
RICH: I’m waiting for the rebuttal.
Theocracy, Natural Rights, and the Tyranny of Liberalism
ADAM: Alright. First of all, you said a lot more about
liberalism than about conservatism, even though liberalism isn’t our topic. But
fine, maybe we can arrive at the nature of conservatism indirectly, by focusing
for a while on its opposite.
So just for starters, your slide from social democracy, or
the so-called liberal establishment, to communism or tyranny is a grotesque
oversimplification. In a democratic country with a capitalistic economy like
the United States, the government needs certain powers to protect the social
fabric and thus to prevent an outbreak of chaos, as in what’s called a failed
state. The selfish impulses that capitalism nurtures are utterly amoral. For
example, enterprising businessmen in early American history had no compunction
against selling slaves; likewise, even today there’s a thriving business of
human trafficking of sex slaves. Responsible governments collect taxes not just
to protect private property or to defend against foreign enemies, but to preserve
the public welfare, which means upholding its culture’s ideals. Slavery is
against both Christian and Enlightenment values, but as long as there’s a
supply of and demand for slaves, capitalism itself isn’t going to end slavery.
Thus, the government needs to step in as a bulwark against capitalistic greed.
I mean, there are a hundred other grotesqueries in your rant,
but let’s leave it there for a minute. Tell us, then, how are all liberal
governments communistic or tyrannical?


















